|“||They don't know the whole story.||”|
|— Clay Jensen|
This episode focuses on Clay Jensen's testimony.
Clay wakes up from a weird dream and goes downstairs to get the newspaper. Written on it is "Hannah lied." Alex is woken up by his mom and wished a "Happy birthday." Tony hangs out with Caleb who confesses that he likes Tony. Tony asks him about the guy with no eye that he beat up and Caleb tells him that the guy is haunted by the assault. Alex goes to school and sees that Zach, Jessica, and Clay have made him a birthday banner that they hung in the hall. Bryce makes fun of him about it and Alex calls him a rapist. This upsets Jessica who leaves him in the hallway with Zach.
Tyler is in the developing room when Mackenzie walks in and asks him to hang out sometime like on a date. Marcus goes to Bryce and shows him the video that Tyler and Cyrus are blackmailing him with. They are telling him to wear a dress at the pep rally or that they're going to show the video to everyone. He asks Bryce for help but he refuses to get involved. Clay tries to tell the court good things about Hannah but Sonya makes him admit that they did spend one night together doing drugs.
Marcus wears a cheerleading uniform to the pep rally but this doesn't appease Tyler who tells Cyrus that they have to think of something bigger. Having returned from court, Clay watches as the baseball team hangs Jeff's Jersey in honor of him. He thinks about the time Jeff invited him over to his house to hang out with him and Hannah. Sheri asks Clay how his testimony went and he tells her that they brought up the party. Alex and his dad are at the Baker's store when they run into Tyler. Alex invites Tyler to his birthday party later that night. Mr. and Mrs. Baker head to Hannah's grave where Mrs. Baker wonders if she passed down her depression gene to Hannah. Mr. Baker tries to comfort her and they kiss spontaneously. Nina takes Jessica shopping. While in the dressing room getting undressed, Jessica remembers the assault and freaks out. She runs out of the store with the dress and starts crying. Nina returns the dress to one of the employees and comforts Jessica. Jessica learns that Nina hasn't told her boyfriend about her rape because she doesn't let what happened to her define her.
Mr and Mrs. Baker have lunch and Mr. Baker brings up finalizing their divorce. Jessica shows up at Alex's birthday party. Alex tries to apologize but Jessica says that they don't need to talk about it. Tyler shows up to the party but Zach and Jessica tell him to leave because of what he did to Hannah. The group breaks down into an argument over Hannah and the trial. Zach gets a call from his Mom and lies with who he's with. Alex kicks him out of the party because he won't admit to being his friend. Alex goes to play one of the shooting video games but his Dad stops him by yanking the controller out of his hands. Alex falls and begins to yell at his friends and family. He says that he should've succeeded in killing himself but Jessica gets mad at him because he wants to leave her behind.
Tyler facetimes Cyrus and tells him that he wants to blackmail Zach next because he's an asshole. After the party, Clay goes to his car and finds another polaroid with "the Clubhouse" written on the back of it. Justin overhears Clay's parents arguing. Clay has a flashback to the morning when Hannah said that she wanted to die. Clay goes home to find his parents watching tv with Justin which upsets him. Chlöe and Bryce are watching a movie on the sofa but Bryce wants to do more than that. He forces her into having sex and Chlöe doesn't seem to be enjoying herself. Jessica sits outside Clay's house watching Justin. Clay is upset because he's reading the comments on the blog. So he decides to upload the tapes to the website so that everyone can know the whole story.
|Internal World||Cloud Nothings||Life Without Sound||Jeff and Clay play pool at Jeff's house / Jeff encourages Clay to try Ecstasy.|
|Into Me||Strange Names||Data||Clay and Hannah talk on the couch in Jeff's basement and they take Ecstasy in Jeffs' basement along with Alex, Sheri, Leah and Jeff himself.|
|Being No One, Going Nowhere||Internal World||Being No One, Going Nowhere||Hannah, Clay, Alex, Sheri Jeff and Leah talk while being high in Jeffs' basement.|
|My Kingdom||Echo & The Bunnymen||Ocean Rain||Clay and Hannah discuss infinity and love in Jeffs' basement while being high.|